BEFORE: OK, last film before I go on vacation, I'll be away all next week and then I'll be back on December 21 or 22 with the final FOUR films of the year, and yes, they will all be Christmas films. The Christmas genre can be a lot like the romance and horror genres, in that they tend to keep using the same actors, or at least there's enough crossover between the films for me to put something together every year.
In years past, I've been happy with ending the year with one or maybe two Christmas films, SEVEN is a bit unheard of, but I'm trying to clear the decks here - maybe next year I'll be back to two, but it's like the other genres, the more films I put on the list, the greater the opportunities for a longer chain. So now that I have my romance chain for 2026 worked out, I can maybe focus on adding some more documentaries once slots open up, then focus on adding more horror films for a while, then I can think about adding some more holiday films for next year, OK?
Jack Black carries over from "A Minecraft Movie".
THE PLOT: When a young boy mails his Christmas wish to Santa with one crucial spelling error, a devilish creature arrives to wreak havoc on the holidays.
AFTER: This film kind of has the same problem as "Family Switch", it's trying too hard to be all things to all the people, all of the time. It's a Christmas film, it's a family film, it's a comedy, it's a school film, it wants to be a romance, and then the simple inclusion of the DEVIL should mean that it's also a horror film, in a way at least. The hardest of these to be, of course, is a comedy. Can somebody find the funny aspects of being tempted to sell one's soul to the devil? It's clearly harder than anyone expected it to be.
AFTER: This film kind of has the same problem as "Family Switch", it's trying too hard to be all things to all the people, all of the time. It's a Christmas film, it's a family film, it's a comedy, it's a school film, it wants to be a romance, and then the simple inclusion of the DEVIL should mean that it's also a horror film, in a way at least. The hardest of these to be, of course, is a comedy. Can somebody find the funny aspects of being tempted to sell one's soul to the devil? It's clearly harder than anyone expected it to be.
Really, this should be a walk in the park, to make this situation funny - we had "Bedazzled" (two versions, even) which succeeded, and "The Devil and Max Devlin" (OK, not so much), but this is a comedy staple, when the devil appears to you and he's got the horns and the pitchfork and a red suit, and he offers you the thing that you want (or here it's three wishes, it seems somebody kind of got Satan mixed up with a genie...) and all you have to do is sign away your soul. There are countless jokes about this situation, to the point where some people maybe think that this could happen, only I maintain that if the devil is in our world and he's looking for souls, he's just not going to be so obvious about it - he'll hide the soul-transfer agreement in some software license that you won't read but WILL click "agree" to, or he'll run a free porn site that you have to click to access, and you wont see that small print under "You must be 18 or older" that reads "and you must agree that the devil gets your soul".
Anyway, he's not going to LOOK like the devil, he'll look like your best friend, or some hot woman like Elizabeth Hurley (if "Bedazzled" got it right) and you won't even know what's happening. Or he'll catch you in your lowest moment, when you're willing to sign away your soul for another chance to finally succeed at something. Or, just hear me out on this one, maybe the Devil isn't real and there's no hell and no heaven and nobody is fighting to get you on their team before the apocalypse comes. Just putting that out there.
So the comedy comes from the fact that here Satan looks like Jack Black (the "best friend" disguise, I mean, who couldn't be friends with Jack Black?) and this dyslexic kid misspells the name on his annual letter to Santa (could happen) and so instead of going to the North Pole, his letter gets sent to the underworld and he gets a very different type of supernatural creature answers his letter. This should have been hilarious and unfortunately it's just NOT, because all of the plot points in the entire movie are debated and re-hashed over and over again, and the movie gets slowed down each time, making it feel like it goes on FOREVER. Any fun we might get by seeing Jack Black appear as a devil at a winter carnival, or on stage at a Post Malone concert, or appearing as tiny Satan in a hamster cage, gets negated by the endless debate over the rules about granting wishes, signing that contract, and searching for any possibly loopholes in the deal and then not finding them.
The secondary stories are even worse, because Liam's parents overhear him talking about Satan and think that their son is either psychotic or delusional, so they hire a child psychologist to analyze him, which goes absolutely nowhere. Liam also forms a friendship with Gibby, a kid from school with enormous teeth, and Liam keeps ditching him and then talking to him via Facetime the next day to apologize and discuss further strategies to outwit the devil. We needed less talking about it and more being about it, I think. The attempts at romance with Liam pursuing a girl named Ella seem more narratively promising, but this story also eventually goes nowhere and comes to a crashing halt. It's like somebody set out to make a movie where nothing ever happens and also nothing is very funny at all.
Is this my fault? Did I program a week of non-entertaining films? Did I maybe watch all the good holiday movies already and now I'm stuck watching all the terrible ones? How come I can re-watch "Bad Santa" every year but I never ever want to watch this one again? It's got to be the movie, right? It's not funny and it's barely Christmas-ey. Meanwhile Liam's parents seem like they're headed for a separation (two Christmases! Woo-hoo!) and eventually we learn the dark thing that happened that's the cause of their dysfunction, but could it be possible that they could come back together as a family, either out of concern for Liam or by communicating and working things out? Or maybe some Christmas magic can put this family back together, here's hoping.
Directed by Bobby Farrelly (director of "Champions" and "Hall Pass")
Also starring Robert Timothy Smith, Keegan-Michael Key (last heard in "The Super Mario Bros. Movie"), Brianne Howey (last seen in "Horrible Bosses 2"), Hayes MacArthur (last seen in "Bachelorette"), Post Malone (last seen in "Happy Gilmore 2"), P.J. Byrne (last seen in "A Complete Unknown"), Jaden Carson Baker, Kai Cech, Cate Freedman, Gavin Munn (last seen in "Dirty Grandpa"), Lee Reyes, Bash Hagelin, Bryson Haney, Selah Kimbro Jones (last seen in "Hidden Figures"), Kyle Gass (last seen in "Sex Drive"), Lindsay Rootare (last seen in "Jerry and Marge Go Large"), Luke Chiappetta, Maiya Moran, Greg Clarkson (last seen in "Superman" (2025)), Travon McEntyre, Abe Farrelly (last seen in "Hall Pass"), Leo Easton Kelly, Izzy Herbert (last seen in "Richard Jewell"), Tierre Turner (last seen in "CHIPS"), with a cameo from Ben Stiller (also last seen in "Happy Gilmore 2")
RATING: 4 out of 10 beer pong cups

